October 04, 2010

Tuesdays At The Table - Peanut Butter and Nutella Cookies

Fall is here...FINALLY!  I'm thrilled at the prospect of using my oven without the chance of sweltering to death to make something tasty!  To celebrate, I'm sharing one of my new favorite cookies.  You can't go wrong with  peanut butter and Nutella makes everything better!

We've had an influx of new participants!  WELCOME!!  Please visit the fabulous ladies who continue to share their amazing recipes each week.  (Really, I'm honored that you all keep coming back.)

Lovely Yellow Ribbons

Peanut Butter and Nutella Cookies

1/2 cup unsalted butter - at room temperature
2/3 cup light brown sugar
1 egg - beaten
3/4 cup + 1 and a half tablespoons self-rising flour
1/2 cup Quaker oats
3 tablespoons Nutella - HEAPING
2 tablespoons smooth peanut butter - HEAPING
Butter, for greasing

Place the butter and sugar in a large bowl and beat them together until pale. Add the egg gradually, beating with the spoon as you go.  Add the flour and the oats and mix well. Finally, add the Nutella and Skippy. Don't mix in them in completely; they need to be nice and swirly.

Use a tablespoon to place blobs of cookie mixture on a greased baking sheet, making sure that they are well spaced as the dough spreads during cooking. Bake for 10–12 minutes at 350 (until slightly browned).

Let the cookies cool for a few minutes before removing them from the baking sheet.
What's cooking in your kitchen?


  1. Cole, this sounds great! I love nutella! I was just reading another blog that used nutella with cheese for a cheese and wine party! Thanks for hosting this blog party -- I love food memes.

  2. Oh, my! We love Nutella and the combo of peanut butter and Nutella is divine!!

  3. Hello,
    I am new to your blog. Nice meme you have here.
    I need to give your recipe a try, it sounds delicious. I am also going to copy it and pass along to a friend of mine who loves Nutella.
    Many blessings to you.

  4. Yum, those sound really good! I love anything with Nutella!

    Thanks for the link party!

  5. Ohhh I love Nutella! If you've never had it, make a peanut butter, banana & nutella sandwich and grill it like a grilled cheese. Best thing I've ever had in my life. I can't keep nutella in the house because I would make these too often!

  6. Your cookies sound perfect! I must try. :)

  7. Mixture of Nutella and peanut butter, yum! Happy Tuesday!

  8. Haven't tried Nutella yet but my friend loves it so I'll pass this along to her.

  9. Nutella... and peanut butter.... ???? Wooot Wooot! These sound DELISH-US!!!

    Thanks for hosting :)

  10. These sound great! I might just be making a batch tommorrow night!

  11. YUM!! I really like nutella so thanks for a great recipe to use it in!!

  12. Oh Cole, those cookies are calling my name! I was eating nutella before ANY of you because my mum is from europe where it is way more popular than peanut butter! Thanks for hosting tuesdays at the table. My recipe this week is for Quick and healthy Saturday Brunch Omlettes. Alex@amoderatelife

  13. I adore Nutella - how nice to have a delicious recipe to try instead of just dipping my spoon in the jar!
    <>< Concetta

  14. Are you kidding. My butt just got bigger reading the recipe ;)

  15. What a perfect combination! Nutella + peanut butter = heavenly! Thanks for hosting!

  16. Well, I love Nutella and I happen to have some in my pantry. Soooo, I'm making these today.


  17. These sound delicious! I used to make PB & Nutella sandwiches in college.

  18. My husband eats Nutella straight out of the jar...bleh...The cookies look great!

    Thanks for hosting. :)

  19. Hubs is going to love these! Isn't awesome to be able to use the oven again? :D

  20. This week I am sharing our favorite way to make green beans!

    And, anyone can come link up their recipes to Dr. Laura's Tasty Tuesdays too:

    Dr. Laura

  21. Thanks for hosting the party! I'm one of your newest followers.

  22. Hi, I just found your site and linked up. I love nutella and don't understand anyone who doesn't, it's a no brainer! Thanks for hosting. BTW my son has your name!

  23. Those cookies sound good! Thanks for the linky!

    Linda @ Linda's Lunacy

  24. jake and i were at the grocery store a few weeks ago and they were giving samples of rice cakes. more importantly, you could top the rice cakes with chocolate, peanut butter, or nutella. i made the hubs try the nutella, he's been DEPRIVED of it. utterly deprived. next up, i shall attempt to incorporate it into our kitchen, starting with this cookie gem.

  25. oh, my those sound RICH! - www.delightfulcountrycookin.com

  26. Oh my gosh your blog is the cutest thing I've ever seen!!! I adore it! Not to mention the puppies are too cute!!!

    Wow, I love the sound of this recipe! So delicious!!!

  27. I love peanut butter. Just blog hopped and found your party! Can't wait to play more often!

    -Krystal @ recipesofacheapskate.blogspot.com


I LOVE comments! Tell me what you're thinking. :-)

Blog Design by Creative Girl Media